Official Backtalk Village Cookie Semi-Semifinals

 What was the first backtalk village post? This one by Infrequently Vile (or as we mostly knew her: Garden Marvel) was the first mentioned and it was about cookies:

ETA: Right now, Peanut Butter cookies are winning. 

Ok, the votes have been tallied, Alan Rickman has departed and the Tivoli report has come back. (They are totally safe and not at all designed to hypnotize you with their goodness. Trust us. TRUST US . . . )

The next to the last round of voting includes:

Tivolis in the lead, with the anti-tivolis splitting the rest of the pack -

Peanut Butter (HOW IS THIS EVEN A THING, PEOPLE?)

Jammie Dodgers

Chocolate Chip

Let the voting battle commence!